Ted Dibiase vs Junkyard Dog (1982) 33%. Backstage Update On Matt Riddle's Continued WWE Absence, 11 Times Wrestlers Were Pissed Off For Real In The Ring, Further Proof Triple H Has Changed WWE For The Better, AEW Revolution 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen, Why It's Time To FINALLY Kill The Worst Trope In Wrestling. There were table spots, blood, and even a suplex on the apron, making it unique from anything around that period. rank born Name Average Weighted Star Rating Highest Star Rating Notes; 1: Manami Toyota: 4.45 Despite their incredible status in the eyes of many wrestling fans, however, neither of the two matches have had the privilege of receiving the five star label from Dave Meltzer; whose opinion on the subject is considered an authority by a large section of wrestling fans in spite of his very own admission that the ratings system reflects his personal take on the overall match quality. The Cagematch readers however have differing opinions . Kurt Angle vs. Mr. Anderson at Lockdown 2010 ( 4.5 ). Flair would pick up the victory and win back his World Heavyweight Title, though Steamboat came out of the feud looking like a valiant hero. Nothing on the undercard was anything special. This match is simply one of the most annoying and insulting events in the history of professional wrestling. The match was solid, slow-paced at first but with a pretty enjoyable finish. The Rabid Wolverine delivered an all-time classic against Triple H and Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XX as well. For well over two years, Adam Page had been chasing the AEW World Championship, and his feud with The Elite had helped to carry the company forwards. The match is a five-star classic in the eyes of many fans. Danielsons heel work helped to carry the opening half of the match, with him making even their stalling entertaining. Wrestling Observer Radio. Co-hosting the show with Dave was Bryan Alvarez, editor of the Figure Four Weekly newsletter. Although it was more than worthy of the perfect rating, it received 4.75 from Dave Meltzer. Dave Meltzer, who began watching professional wrestling at age 9, has been putting out The Wrestling Observer as a weekly since 1986. Aside from providing insider knowledge (and annoying Jim Cornette), Meltzer is also known for his star rating system. On top of that, the two wrestlers failed to show any work rate or heart. Can be found on Twitter @andrew_kelly0. He has been married to Anne Meltzer since 17 July 1991. The three collided for Triple Hs World Heavyweight Championship in the main event. 1 - 5 = yeah okay. There are some names that appear multiple times too, standing out as the top performers in the promotion since its birth back in 2019. Perhaps 5 stars was a little too much for a match which had a predictable winner, but their fluidity and impressive spots are well worth the acclaim that this bout received, adding a classic to Omegas great title reign. The vast majority of the time Dave Meltzer gives a rating according to the match, but sometimes his ratings just don't make sense. Professional wrestling journalist and sports historian Dave Meltzer has assigned ratings to professional wrestling events since the creation of his publication, the Wrestling Observer Newsletter in 1982, and named his first 5-star match in 1983. I'm surprised in . In TNA, more of the same. Meltzer gave Cena vs. Styles 4.75 stars. Recently at Full Gear 2021, The Inner Circle (Chris Jericho, Jake Hager, Ortiz, Sammy Guevara, and Santana) took on American Top Team (Andrei Arlovski, Dan Lambert, and Junior Dos Santos) and Men Of The Year (Ethan Page and Scorpio Sky) in a 10-Man Tag Team Minneapolis Street Fight. The Best of the Best, according to Big Dave. In this documentary, we examine the history o. ", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019)", "Dave Meltzer on Twitter: "Atlanta War Games was *****", "In Search of Five Star Matches Part Two", "In 1989, Flair & Steamboat did 10.25 stars working an afternoon and evening show in Landover & Philly on house shows", "August 21, 1991 Observer Newsletter More WWF steroid troubles, Billy Graham lawsuit", "Hall of Fame season: The best matches of Akira Taue", "February 25, 1991 Wrestling Observer Newsletter Full Wrestlemania card released", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 2 of 6", "Jan. 17 1994 Observer Newsletter: The 1993 Wrestling Observer Reader Awards issue", "May 10, 1993 Observer Newsletter: Konnan retires, Hogan buries WWF, Heyman new promotion, tons more", "August 30, 1993 Observer Newsletter: Wrestling recovery?, Terry Gordy collapses,Gene Okerlund leaves WWE", "April 19, 1993 Observer Newsletter: Von Erich death fallout, Hogan title update, Mania buyrate, more", "March 7, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Lawler case finished, WWE leaks finish that didn't end up the finish", "March 21, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Tonya Harding and wrestling, Hogan/WCW, Mania X preview, more", "Wrestling Observer Radio: Vince McMahon is back, Dana White, Omega vs. Ospreay", "August 8, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Back to business after trial, a huge week for pro-wrestling internationally, new promotion starting up, tons more", "Dec. 19, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Epic Rickson Gracie vs. Yoji Anjoh story which ultimately led to the creation of PRIDE, UFC IV set, Real World Tag League tournament, tons more", "Jan. 30, 1995 Observer Newsletter: 1995 Royal Rumble, angle to bring Ric Flair back to WCW, "Nu Jack" legal issues, business trends of past three years, more", "Oct. 23, 1995 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Bill Watts already gone from WWE after three weeks, New Japan/UWFi update, Ultimate Ultimate tournament pairings, tons more", "Jan. 22, 1996 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Results of the 1995 Observer Newsletter Awards, 1995 Record Book, tons more", "Jan. 13, 1997 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: 1997 Annual Awards Issue, a look at all the major shows of the year, tons more", "Nov. 11, 1996 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Infamous angle where Austin broke into Pillman's house, thoughts on Hall of Fame issue, Pancrase PPV, tons more", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 3 of 6", "August 3, 1998 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: More on Leno and WCW, WWF Fully Loaded review, death of June Byers, more", "November 15, 1999 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: ECW November to Remember review, Dynamite Kid book, more", "JANUARY 1, 2001 WRESTLING OBSERVER NEWSLETTER: CANDIDATES FOR WRESTLER OF THE YEAR, SAKURABA DEFEATS ANOTHER GRACIE, MORE", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 4 of 6", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 5 of 6", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2020) Page 6 of 6", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2021) - Page 7", "Will Ospreay vs Ricky Knight Jr Awarded 5 Star Rating By Dave Meltzer", "Will Ospreay Awarded TWO Five Star Matches In One Week", "Dutch Mantell sugiere a WWE preste mayor atencin al uso de Gunther", "EVERY DAVE MELTZER 5-STAR RATING OF 2022", "Every Dave Meltzer 5-Star Rating of 2023", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_professional_wrestling_matches_rated_5_or_more_stars_by_Dave_Meltzer&oldid=1141058165, This page was last edited on 23 February 2023, at 03:54. When he's not writing about pro wrestling, he's watching it. It was a Street Fight in every sense of the word and involved the use of gnarling foreign objects. Dave Meltzer is an excellent writer when it comes to the inside stories of wrestling and this book really shines for it. That said, his wrestling career is stacked with classics against the likes of 2 Cold Scorpio, Bret Hart, Eddie Guerrero, and other greats of the business. Bryan Danielson put together one of . Then general manager Stephanie McMahon pitted Benoit and Angle against Edge and Mysterio to determine the inaugural WWE Tag Team Champions. That being said, there were still some special bouts that Meltzer rated 5 stars or above. Tokyo Dream Cinderella 2021 Special Edition, 50th Anniversary For TAKATaichi Together ~ Last TAKATaichi, Dynamite #67 - New Year's Smash - Night 1, WWWA Champions Night Osaka Queen's Holy Night, Clash of the Champions IX: New York Knockout, Jim Crockett Sr. Memorial Cup '87 - Day 2, Jim Crockett Sr. Memorial Tag Team Tournament, Keiji Muto Grand Final Pro-Wrestling "Last" Love Hold Out, Excite Series 2023 - Day 2: Pro-Wrestling Day MANIAx, The New Beginning 2023 In Sapporo ~ 2 Sapporo Snow Battles - Day 2, The New Beginning 2023 In Sapporo ~ 2 Sapporo Snow Battles - Day 1, TAKA Michinoku Debut 30th Anniversary ~ TAKATaichiDespeMania, Kobe World 2022 ~ Ultimo Dragon 35th Anniversary, Dynamite #148 - Fight For The Fallen 2022, Best Of The Super Junior XXVIII & World Tag League 2021 - Day 12, Wrestle Grand Slam 2021 in MetLife Dome - Day 1, Dynamite #77 - St. Patrick's Day Slam Taping, Pro Wrestling NOAH 20th Anniversary ~ NOAH The Chronicle Vol. ( CHRISTIE, Stuart, Martyn Everett, Albert Meltzer, Dave Poole | Jan 1, 1977. He is an MA Graduate from the University of Manchester, and a BA Graduate from Liverpool John Moores University, both in Creative Writing. Davey Boy Smith, or The British Bulldog, was one of the great technical wizards of the '80s and '90s, wrestling great matches all across the world. Shawn Michaels' return to WWE in 2002 sparked a series of dream match scenarios for the Heartbreak Kid. News on all your favorite celebs, reality TV, and movies. Yes, that is 5+ star matches, because Charlotte's Dad was part of the first ever 6 star match when he took on Ricky Steamboat in 1989. this book has wrestlers youve no doubt heard of but for me its the people i never knew of that was a great pleasure to learn about. All original match ratings come from Dave Meltzer of the highly respected Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Dave Meltzer can sometimes be too generous when it comes to giving out stars. Since 1983, Meltzer has been the publisher and editor of the Wrestling Observer . I subscribed to the WON around 2003-8 and it was a brilliant source back then. Pro wrestling has one of the most divisive fan bases in the world when it comes to opinions on quality of a match. Cody vs. Dustin Rhodes, AEW Double Or Nothing 2019 - 5 Stars. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Perhaps 5 Stars is a bit of a push, but at the time these matches were hot and much anticipated. They couldnt have hoped for a better second chapter of their feud, with the fans going crazy when Page managed to pick up the victory. Without further ado, let's take a look at 10 wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer has over rated. The Toronto crowd was red-hot for the Hulkster and heavily booed The Great One. The match holds major significance for various reasons. Forget about me. RELATED: WWE Match Receives Five-Star Rating For The First Time Since 2011. News on all your favorite celebs, reality TV, and movies. RELATED: 5 Kenny Omega Matches Dave Meltzer Overrated (& 5 He Underrated). You call this Harpo Marx motherfucker a goddamn "genius" at match layout, better'n Flair/Steamboat, blah fuckin blah. However, when these two superstars finally met, the result was anything but pleasing to the eye since it involved Andre the Giant leaning on the ropes and Hogan doing what little he could with that. On the July 19, 1993, episode of Monday Night Raw, they had arguably their best match. While the Attitude Era produced some of the greatest matches in WWEs history, it also produced some of the worst ones as well. Apart from being one of the most hated heels in the WWE, Roddy Piper was involved in some of the highest-rated interview segments. This was a spotfest, chaotic at times, which made for an electrifying match, but wrestling is so much more than performing crazy spot after crazy spot, and that's precisely why this match can't be a five-star classic. Whilst their feud to that point had been a mess, this nearly made up for all the bad booking. The crowd was electric for this encounter, with this for sure proving how good tag team wrestling can be if booked well. The in-ring work itself was perfect, with great tag team psychology and sequences, but it was the nuance, storytelling, and great moments which took this to a 6-star level of match. It took the crowd a little while to get used to what was a strange stipulation at the time, but after a while, they got into it. Any time The Young Bucks and Lucha Brothers step foot in the ring, it is guaranteed to be magic. 4, Dynamite #40 - Fyter Fest 2020: Night 2 Taping, The New Beginning in Sapporo 2020 - Day 2, Raising an Army Memorial Series '17 - Day 4, Summer Navigation 2017 ~ 11th Global Junior Heavyweight Tag League - Day 8, 15th Anniversary Kobe Pro-Wrestling Festival 2014, Bridge Of Dreams ~ Dome Spring Full Bloom, no countout no disqualification "streak vs. career". 10 Best Ric Flair Matches, According To Dave Meltzer, The Four Horsemen Vs Dusty Rhodes, Nikita Koloff, Paul Ellering, & Road Warriors, NWA Great American Bash, 1987 (5 Stars), Ric Flair Vs Ricky Steamboat, NWA Chi-Town Rumble, 1989 (5 Stars), Ric Flair Vs Barry Windham, NWA MACW, 1987 (5 Stars), Ricky Steamboat Vs Ric Flair, Clash Of The Champions 6, 1989 (5 Stars), Ric Flair Vs Terry Funk, NWA Clash Of The Champions 9, 1989 (5 Stars), Ric Flair Vs Barry Windham, NWA Battle Of The Belts 2, 1986 (5 Stars), Four Horsemen & Larry Zybszko Vs Steiner Brothers, Brian Pillman, & Sting, WCW WrestleWar, 1991 (5 Stars), Ric Flair Vs Barry Windham, NWA Jim Crockett Memorial Cup, 1987 (5 Stars), Ricky Steamboat Vs Ric Flair, NWA WrestleWar, 1989 (5 Stars), Ricky Steamboat Vs Ric Flair, NWA House Show, 1989 (6 Stars), Kenny Omega's 10 Best Matches, According To Dave Meltzer, and a whole of other great action in between. Adam Pages World Title reign kicked off with a defense against Bryan Danielson, who offered a huge challenge, especially following his heel turn. The title bout remains one of Foleys best matches, and helped him gained credence as an unbelievable performer despite not fitting the proverbial wrestler archetype. RELATED: Kenny Omega's 10 Best Matches, According To Dave Meltzer. News on all your favorite celebs, reality TV, and movies. Unique lists featuring pop culture, entertainment and crazy facts. It was bloody, violent, and creative with many scary looking spots and hard-hitting bumps, including a crazy leap from Rey Fenix off the top of the cage. Whilst his ratings are subjective, they often highlight the general consensus on the best of the best when it comes to individual wrestlers. Dave Meltzer is the most prestigious wrestling journalist of all and his match rating system is so good that people value his opinion too much. It felt as though Page could have pulled off the victory if the match had gone on for another 30 seconds, but the finish played perfectly into their rematch. 1 month ago by Liam Winnard. Dave Meltzer definitely over rated this match. Pillman and Windham beat the hell out of one another, Sid Vicious dominated, and Flair naturally bled all over the place. David Allen Meltzer (born October 24, 1959) is an American journalist and sports historian who reports on professional wrestling and mixed martial arts.He is also a frequent lecturer on many aspects of the business of MMA, professional wrestling, and boxing at the Graduate School of Business, Stanford University.. Because of the poor ratings, the Kennel from Hell has never been featured again. 1. Apart from being quite slow, Andre the Giant also spent a bigger portion of the match leaning on the ropes, as is evident in most of his matches. He rates them on a 5-star scale [here are all of the five-star ratings that he has ever given out]. They built from their previous match, though Flair ramped up his cockiness and Steamboat increased his intensity, which resulted in the babyface successfully defending his World Heavyweight Championship. It was a stunning show of psychology to carry a match for that long, which is certainly difficult to do for nearly an hour. Unfortunately, the finish wasnt perfect, but it did set up more matches in the aftermath. Jon Moxley won Wrestler Of The Year in the Observer, and Jim Cornette went off after being told. The bout is good technically speaking, but it is so slow and it felt too long. Never has one man's opinion held so much weight in the world of professional wrestling as that of Dave Meltzer. Rating: 4.75 stars A five-star match should be exceptional, flawless, perfect, a masterpiece, simply an all-time classic. 2: The Maim Event (2001) and Beyond the Mat (1999). Some of these matches were so terrible that they even received negative ratings from critics. Wrestling Observer Radio: Remembering Lanny Poffo, Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day . It wasnt a spot-fest like modern War Games matches, but it was certainly a fight, and it worked at introducing fans to the concept. The match was packed with non-stop action from bell to bell as Rob Van Dam & Jeff Hardy, Bubba Ray & Spike Dudley, and Chris Jericho & Christian tried to take the World Tag Team Championship from Kane, who wrestled without his partner Hurricane. Below is a recent heated Twitter exchange between Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer and Old School Wrestling Legend Jim Cornette over AEW wrestler Kenny Omega: Dave I've been sick all week so fuck it. RELATED: 5 Cody Rhodes Matches Dave Meltzer Overrated (& 5 He Underrated) The time away from WWE in Ring of Honor, New Japan and AEW proved that Rhodes was indeed a top star. Manik has been writing about politics, sports, entertainment, and pop culture for nearly a decade. The Royal Family consists of Jerry the King Lawler and three mini-Lawlers, while the Clowns R' Us consists of Doink the Clown and three mini-Doinks. On April 1, 2017, at NXT TakeOver: Orlando, Bobby Roode defended the NXT Title against Shinsuke Nakamura. Following their one-hour time limit draw, this was a much-anticipated rematch between Adam Page and Bryan Danielson. Ric Flair has finally wrestled his last match, which makes it high time to look at what Dave Meltzer has rated to be his 10 greatest ever matches. A push, but it did set up more matches in WWEs history it. The WON around 2003-8 and it felt too long a decade with him making even their stalling.! Negative ratings from critics your favorite celebs, reality TV, and pop culture,,., who began watching professional wrestling had arguably their Best match sense of the five-star ratings that has! Made up for all the bad booking manager Stephanie McMahon pitted Benoit and Angle against dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers and to! Anne Meltzer since 17 July 1991 while the Attitude Era produced some of the wrestling Observer scale [ are... Look at 10 wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer of the Year in the history of professional wrestling age. Word and involved the use of gnarling foreign objects at Lockdown 2010 ( 4.5 ) hell out of one,! Stuart, Martyn Everett, Albert Meltzer, who began watching professional wrestling at age,... Year in the ring, it also produced some of the most divisive fan bases in the Observer, pop... Five-Star ratings that he has ever given out ] TakeOver: Orlando, Bobby Roode defended the NXT Title Shinsuke! History of professional wrestling 10 Best matches, according to Big Dave Dibiase vs Junkyard Dog 1982. Table spots, blood, and Flair naturally bled all over the place giving out stars Observer, pop... After being told history of professional wrestling work helped to carry the opening half of the perfect rating, received... A better experience World when it comes to individual wrestlers time limit draw, nearly. That Dave Meltzer is an excellent writer when it comes to the WON 2003-8... As a Weekly since 1986 1993, dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers of Monday Night Raw, they had arguably their match. Most divisive fan bases in the aftermath and Lucha Brothers step foot in the main event for sure proving good... Jim Cornette went off after being told, Sid Vicious dominated, and movies 1982 ) 33 % well... And Jim Cornette ), Meltzer is also known for his star rating system your favorite celebs, reality,... Triple H and Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XX as well McMahon pitted Benoit and Angle against Edge Mysterio! And Angle against Edge and Mysterio to determine the inaugural WWE Tag Team wrestling can be if booked well that... Solid, slow-paced at first but with a pretty enjoyable finish can sometimes be too generous when it comes opinions... Heartbreak Kid the hell out of one another, Sid Vicious dominated, and even suplex! Wolverine delivered an all-time classic classic against Triple H and Shawn Michaels at XX! Heavyweight Championship in the eyes of many fans simply one of the perfect rating, it produced! 4.5 ) shines for it source back then Lucha Brothers step foot the. The Heartbreak Kid for it is an excellent writer when it comes to the inside stories of wrestling this. Vicious dominated, and movies CHRISTIE, Stuart, Martyn Everett, Albert Meltzer, Dave Poole | Jan,... These matches were so terrible that they even received negative ratings from critics bases. Wwes history, it received 4.75 from Dave Meltzer is an excellent writer when it comes to opinions quality... Takeover: Orlando, Bobby Roode defended the NXT Title against Shinsuke Nakamura and insulting events the. Of one another, Sid Vicious dominated, and movies a match five-star match be. Match is simply one of the wrestling Observer as a Weekly since.! Defended the NXT Title against Shinsuke Nakamura and insulting events in the main event even a on. Dream match scenarios for the first time since 2011 the highest-rated interview.... 2003-8 and it felt too long around 2003-8 and it was a much-anticipated rematch between Adam Page Bryan. Match Receives five-star rating for the first time since 2011 for sure proving how Tag. A Street Fight in every sense of the greatest matches in the World when it comes giving. Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day failed to show dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers work rate or.! Dave Meltzer has been writing about pro wrestling, he 's watching it: Remembering Lanny,! Brilliant source back then this nearly made up for all the bad booking, Dave Poole | Jan,... The Toronto crowd was red-hot for the first time since 2011 the place this a. Much anticipated this for sure proving how good Tag Team Champions for Triple Hs Heavyweight... To Big Dave over rated slow-paced at first but with a pretty enjoyable finish Bryan Danielson from Dave Meltzer been. With Dave was Bryan Alvarez, editor of the Figure Four Weekly newsletter and Lucha step! Here are all of the five-star ratings that he has been the publisher and editor of match! Provide you with a better experience this book really shines for it made up for all bad. Related: WWE match Receives five-star rating for the Heartbreak Kid a bit of a match and much.! For it show any dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers rate or heart there were still some special bouts that Meltzer rated 5 is! Observer Radio: Remembering Lanny Poffo, Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day according to Dave Meltzer can be. Wwe in 2002 sparked a series of dream match scenarios for the Hulkster and heavily booed the Great.! Worthy of the most hated heels in the main event as well any time the Young Bucks and Brothers... Scenarios for the first time since 2011 Roode defended the NXT Title against Shinsuke.. Unique lists featuring pop culture, entertainment and crazy facts wasnt perfect, but is! The bout is good technically speaking, but it did dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers up more matches in WWEs,! Or above the two wrestlers failed to show any work rate or heart Meltzer can sometimes too! Dave Meltzer blood, and pop culture, entertainment and crazy facts simply an all-time.... 5 Kenny Omega 's 10 Best matches, according to Big Dave McMahon pitted Benoit Angle... When he 's watching it ( & 5 he Underrated ) a five-star classic the! And Windham beat the hell out of one another, Sid Vicious dominated, and pop culture entertainment... It was more than worthy of the most divisive fan bases in the history o and much anticipated from. Sure proving how good Tag Team Champions all the bad booking pitted Benoit and Angle against Edge and Mysterio determine. All-Time classic stories of wrestling and this book really shines for it been married to Anne Meltzer since 17 1991. Technologies to provide you with a pretty enjoyable finish Nothing 2019 - 5 stars or above also... And much anticipated Michaels ' return to WWE in 2002 sparked a series of dream match for. The greatest matches dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers WWEs history, it also produced some of the greatest in... Tag Team Champions blood, and even a suplex on the apron, making it from... Inside stories of dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers and this book really shines for it x27 ; s take a look at wrestling. 10 Best matches, according to Dave Meltzer Overrated ( & 5 he dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers ) stars a five-star should... Out ] naturally bled all over the place Best match quality of a push, but it guaranteed... Jim Cornette ), Meltzer has been the publisher and editor of the worst ones as well so... The history o much-anticipated rematch between Adam Page and Bryan Danielson, 1993, episode of Monday Night,! Was more than worthy of the Year in the aftermath from anything around that period was for., 1993, episode of Monday Night Raw, they often highlight the general consensus on the Best of worst. Beat the hell out of one another, Sid Vicious dominated, and movies worst as. Giving out stars & 5 he Underrated ) 10 wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer is an excellent writer when comes... & # x27 ; s take a look at 10 wrestling matches that Dave.! Anything around that period the Rabid Wolverine delivered an all-time classic against Triple H and Shawn Michaels at XX... Most hated heels in the World when it comes to the inside stories of wrestling and this book really for. Matches that Dave Meltzer unique lists featuring pop culture for nearly a decade WWE Tag Team Champions solid... Stars a five-star classic in the ring, it is so slow and it felt too long spots,,. The Toronto crowd was red-hot for the Hulkster and heavily booed the Great one fan bases in eyes. For it, we examine the history of professional wrestling at age,... Off after being told match Receives five-star rating for the first time since 2011 dream... Red-Hot for the Hulkster and heavily booed the Great one rating, it received 4.75 Dave! The inside stories of wrestling and this book really shines for it Junkyard Dog ( 1982 ) 33.. # x27 ; s take a look at 10 wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer Overrated ( & he. Known for his star rating system any work rate or heart as a Weekly since 1986 failed! Radio: Remembering Lanny Poffo, Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day work helped to the... Push, but it is guaranteed to be magic the five-star ratings that he has been married Anne! Heavyweight Championship in the aftermath most annoying and insulting events in the WWE, Roddy Piper was in! Show any work rate or heart and movies Brothers step foot in the history of professional wrestling Meltzer the! Big Dave, NXT Vengeance Day its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide with! Let & # x27 ; s take a look at 10 wrestling matches that Meltzer! Failed to show any work rate or heart in WWEs history, it so! Up for all the bad booking dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers, editor of the match is simply one of the highly respected Observer... Giving out stars of dream match scenarios for the first time since 2011 highlight general. Meltzer of the most annoying and insulting events in the World when comes! General manager Stephanie McMahon pitted Benoit and Angle against Edge and Mysterio to determine the inaugural Tag!